Envelope 1 - Chapter 11 Plan Terms
Envelope 1's amended Chapter 11 plan centers on a contract manufacturing model funded by postpetition operations and capital advances from Gainshare Equity Group, which will receive the reorganized Debtor's equity in exchange for new value as existing equity is cancelled. The Debtor will surrender its Columbiana, Ohio, real property and idled surplus equipment to secured lenders, including U.S. Eagle Federal Credit Union, which holds an approximately $23.8 million claim and will also receive $314,727 over 60 months for retained equipment, while general unsecured creditors will recover 2% of allowed claims in up to 20 quarterly installments. Spectrum Commercial Finance will receive a $300,000 lump sum on the Effective Date in full satisfaction of its $958,738.40 claim, though according to the Debtor, Gainshare's missed second installment under a court-approved $600,000 discounted payoff entitles Spectrum to its default amount.
Plan Terms
Overview
- Envelope 1, Inc. filed its combined and amended disclosure statement and plan of reorganization on Nov. 13, 2026. The plan pays general unsecured creditors 2% of allowed claims over no more than 20 quarterly installments. The debtor will surrender its Columbiana, Ohio, real property and idle surplus equipment to secured lenders in satisfaction of their claims. Existing equity is cancelled, and new shares go to plan sponsor Gainshare Equity Group, LLC in exchange for new value. The plan has not been confirmed.
- The debtor makes made-to-order envelopes for companies and institutions, primarily in North America. It filed for Chapter 11 in West Palm Beach, Florida, on Nov. 12, 2025. Before filing, it had invested in real property improvements, including a new 100,000-square-foot digital printing facility, and taken on an eight-figure increase in leveraged financing at interest rates above 15%. It has since operated as a smaller manufacturer on a cash basis.
- Plan payments are funded by postpetition operations and by Gainshare capital advances for paper and related materials under a contract manufacturing model. Gainshare also takes over management after confirmation.
- Spectrum Commercial Finance, LLC's secured claim was to be bought out for $600,000 under a court-approved settlement. Gainshare paid the first $300,000 installment but not the second. The plan acknowledges that Spectrum is therefore entitled to a default amount of $958,738.40, less payments received, plus interest. Even so, it proposes to pay Spectrum a $300,000 lump sum on the effective date in full satisfaction.
Administrative and Priority Claims
- Fees for the debtor's counsel, estimated at $40,000, are payable on the effective date or as otherwise agreed. Any unpaid court fees under 28 U.S.C. § 1930 are paid by the effective date.
- Priority wage claims total $315,781.76 and are paid in full in 48 monthly installments of $6,578.62 beginning on the effective date, although the same provision says payments will not run longer than one year from the order for relief. The liquidation analysis instead puts priority wage claims at $238,506.12. Pidgeon family members, whom the plan identifies as insiders, will waive payment on their claims to the extent needed to pay third-party wage claimants.
- The IRS filed Claim 98 for zero, asserting no priority tax claim. The Ohio Department of Taxation filed Claim 19, a priority claim for unpaid workers' compensation insurance premiums based on an estimated maximum premium; the plan leaves the amount blank. The debtor will file information to correct the premiums owed and will pay the claim in equal monthly installments with statutory interest within five years of the order for relief. The liquidation analysis puts priority tax claims at more than $164,990.66.
Classification and Treatment of Claims and Interests
- The plan has 22 classes: 20 classes of secured claims, one class of general unsecured claims (Class 21, listed in Exhibit A to the plan) and one class of equity interests. The debtor says it believes all classes are impaired and all holders of allowed claims may vote, but the plan labels Classes 3, 13 and 14 unimpaired.
- The debtor ranks prepetition liens by priority. It says the liens of Spectrum and U.S. Eagle Federal Credit Union are worth more than the collateral pledged to later lenders, and it ranks purchase-money lenders ahead of earlier-filed blanket liens on their specific equipment. It says its merger with E1 Digital Direct, Inc. did not affect creditors' rights or lien priority, because all purchase-money liens predate the merger and attach to specific equipment.
- Class 1, Alternative Finance, LLC purchase-money equipment claim (impaired, entitled to vote): The debtor surrenders the digital printing equipment and servers securing Alternative's claim in full satisfaction of the $2.25 million listed on the debtor's Schedule D. Alternative filed no proof of claim. The debtor says the scheduled amount was overstated because it included equipment financed by Pidgeon Farms, LLC and a related entity, which neither the debtor nor E1 Digital Direct used.
- The surrender replaces an early-case agreement to settle the claim for $1,069,725, payable in 60 monthly installments of $17,828.75. That agreement was never formalized or submitted for court approval. The debtor says it lacks the resources to restart E1 Digital Direct's digital printing business and has not used the equipment since filing.
- Alternative's lien is perfected by a UCC filing made Jan. 5, 2022. Its original purchase-money financing statement, filed March 24, 2021, was still of record when U.S. Eagle filed its blanket UCC on Dec. 15, 2021. Alternative terminated filings on Jan. 18, 2022, and April 21, 2022; the debtor was told those filings covered fully depreciated equipment that has since been disposed of.
- Class 1 treats the surrender as full satisfaction of the scheduled amount, but Exhibit A also lists Alternative Finance as a Class 21 creditor at $2.25 million with a $45,000 distribution.
- Class 2, Wintrust Specialty Finance secured claim (impaired, entitled to vote): Wintrust's $303,783.28 claim (Claim 44) is secured up to $70,000. The debtor pays that amount with 8% interest in no more than 60 monthly installments of $1,419.35, beginning on the effective date. Wintrust keeps its purchase-money lien on a 2024 W+D 249 envelope folding machine. The lien was originally granted to Verdant LLC, perfected Sept. 16, 2024 and assigned to Wintrust on Aug. 28, 2025. Exhibit A lists Wintrust in Class 21 at $233,783.28.
- Class 3, Columbiana County secured claim (unimpaired, per the plan): The county's $56,992.81 claim (Claim 36) asserts a lien on the real property that is also subject to U.S. Eagle's mortgage. Because the debtor is surrendering that property to the creditors with liens on it, the secured portion of the claim is extinguished on the effective date with no secured distribution.
- Class 4, U.S. Eagle Federal Credit Union secured claim (impaired, entitled to vote): The debtor surrenders the real property at 42059 State Route 344, Columbiana, Ohio, and any machinery on or attached to it, including Truepress Jet 520ZZ dual-engine press #2021, in full satisfaction of U.S. Eagle's $23.8 million claim (Claim 92). Separately, the debtor has listed and valued the specific equipment it needs to keep operating and will pay U.S. Eagle $314,727 in 60 monthly installments of $5,245.45.
- U.S. Eagle holds a first mortgage on the real property. It also asserts a blanket lien on all of the debtor's assets under a security agreement and a UCC filing dated Dec. 15, 2021, and an intercreditor agreement with Spectrum dated Jan. 7, 2022.
- During the case, the debtor found that the U.S. Eagle building encroaches on the adjoining lot, which is owned by NuBridge Commercial Lending LLC and is where the debtor runs its envelope manufacturing. The encroachment means setback and easement requirements are not met and causes related compliance violations. The debtor says it cannot afford to fix the encroachment or buy the NuBridge lot, considers the property unmarketable and cannot assign it significant value.
- A substantially identical second press, #2017, was removed by M2 Equipment Finance as its purchase-money lender. A serial-number error was corrected, so U.S. Eagle keeps press #2021.
- Class 5, U.S. Small Business Administration secured claim (impaired, entitled to vote): The SBA's $2.26 million claim (Claim 39) is treated as unsecured in Class 21. The SBA asserts a blanket lien on personal property, receivables, inventory and equipment, perfected March 28, 2022, which the debtor says ranks below the liens of U.S. Eagle and Spectrum.
- Class 6, Spectrum Commercial Finance, LLC secured claim (impaired, entitled to vote): The debtor proposes to pay Spectrum a $300,000 lump sum on the effective date in full satisfaction of its $958,738.40 claim (Claim 70). The plan proposes this even though it acknowledges Spectrum is entitled to its default amount under the court-approved settlement described below. Spectrum holds a blanket lien perfected July 8, 2020, subject to its intercreditor agreement with U.S. Eagle, and a first lien on receivables.
- Classes 7 through 12, blanket-lien claims of merchant cash advance funders and Breakout Capital (each impaired, entitled to vote): The debtor objects under section 506 to treating any of these claims as secured. It argues its assets are worth no more than the claims of Spectrum, U.S. Eagle, Alternative Finance and Wintrust, and, for Classes 8 through 12, the SBA. Each asserted lien is extinguished on the effective date with no secured distribution, and each claim is treated in Class 21:
- Class 7, Top Tier Capital: $125,566.84 (Claim 7) under a merchant cash advance agreement backed by a UCC filing dated May 28, 2025; Exhibit A lists the claim at $122,566.84
- Class 8, Diamond Funding: $1.92 million (Claim 91), under a merchant cash advance agreement dated May 28, 2025
- Class 9, Orange Funding: $806,259 (Claim 65), under a merchant cash advance agreement dated May 30, 2025
- Class 10, Prosperium Capital Partners LLC (a/k/a Arsenal Funding): $342,700 (Claim 29), under a merchant cash advance agreement dated May 30, 2025
- Class 11, Dynasty Capital: $140,000 (Claim 4), under a merchant cash advance agreement dated June 5, 2025; the Class 11 objection and lien-extinguishment language names Claim 29 and Prosperium rather than Dynasty
- Class 12, Breakout Capital, LLC: $352,374.62 (Claim 89), under a business loan and security agreement backed by a UCC filing dated Feb. 5, 2025
- Classes 13 through 18, equipment-secured claims: The debtor surrenders, or has already surrendered, each lender's equipment collateral in satisfaction of its secured claim. Each lien is extinguished with no secured distribution, and deficiency claims are treated in Class 21:
- Class 13, North Mill Equipment Finance (unimpaired, per the plan): purchase-money collateral surrendered in full satisfaction of Claim 20; Exhibit A lists North Mill at $150,507.68
- Class 14, QL Titling Trust LTD/Quality Leasing Co. (unimpaired, per the plan): $84,000 claim (Claim 47); collateral already surrendered, with the lien extinguished as of the surrender
- Class 15, Onset Financial, Inc. (impaired, entitled to vote): $329,578.50 purchase-money claim (Claim 84); $705,900.20 deficiency treated in Class 21
- Class 16, M2 Equipment Finance, LLC (impaired, entitled to vote): originally asserted a $300,000 purchase-money claim (Claim 87); M2 netted only $17,875 from selling the surrendered collateral; U.S. Eagle asserts that its blanket lien moved into first priority on that equipment by operation of law; Class 16 puts M2's deficiency at $453,525, but Exhibit A lists M2 at $171,400
- Class 17, Ameris Bank (impaired, entitled to vote): $253,308.15 purchase-money claim (Claim 95); Exhibit A lists Ameris Bank (Balboa Cap) at $131,308.15
- Class 18, First Business Bank (impaired, entitled to vote): $200,000 purchase-money claim (Claim 96); $59,123.88 deficiency treated in Class 21
- Class 19, M&P Logistics judgment-lien claim (impaired, entitled to vote): Mackenzie and Page Logistics, LLC asserts a judgment lien on the surrendered real property. The lien is extinguished on the effective date with no secured distribution, and the $2.59 million unsecured portion of the claim is treated in Class 21.
- The plan identifies both this claim and Columbiana County's Class 3 claim as Claim 36 in the amount of $56,992.81.
- Class 19 puts the unsecured portion at $2.59 million, but Exhibit A lists M&P Logistics at $59,800 under Claim 75.
- Class 20, NuBridge Commercial Lending LLC secured claim (impaired, entitled to vote): NuBridge's $5.67 million claim (Claim 85) rests on a final foreclosure judgment against real property owned by a nondebtor entity, which redirects rent owed to that entity to NuBridge. The debtor says no collateral secures the claim because it has paid no rent to the landlord. The debtor rejects any lease with the nondebtor entity as of the effective date, any judgment lien against the debtor is extinguished, and NuBridge receives no secured distribution.
- Class 21, general unsecured claims (impaired, entitled to vote): Each holder receives 2% of its allowed claim in no more than 20 quarterly installments beginning on the effective date. Exhibit A, which lists these creditors under a Class 19 heading rather than Class 21, puts total 2% distributions at $389,042.23. It includes claims held by Brooke Pidgeon ($1.02 million), Barry Pidgeon ($900,000) and Michael Pidgeon ($93,882.70).
- Class 22, equity interests (impaired, not entitled to vote): The shares held by Tarry Pidgeon, the debtor's president, and Sharon Pidgeon are cancelled. Shares of the reorganized debtor are issued to Gainshare.
Spectrum Settlement and Default
- Under a court-approved settlement, the debtor, Gainshare or a Gainshare affiliate was to buy Spectrum's secured claim for $600,000 by taking an assignment of Spectrum's loan documents. Gainshare paid the first $300,000 installment but has not paid the second. The plan states that Spectrum is therefore entitled to its default amount.
- Discounted payoff: $300,000 due by July 31, 2026 and $300,000 due by Sept. 30, 2026, paid by wire or another method Spectrum chooses. Together the two payments fully satisfy the debtor's obligations to Spectrum. Spectrum does not have to assign its loan documents until it receives the full $600,000.
- Default: Missing the payoff deadlines is an event of default. If it is not cured within five business days after Spectrum's written notice, Spectrum is entitled, without further notice or hearing, to $958,738.40 less payments received, plus interest at the rate in the loan documents or applicable law. Payments go first to interest and then to principal. To the extent the approval order allows, Spectrum also gets relief from the automatic stay, any discharge injunction and any plan injunction to collect the balance.
Plan Sponsor, Funding and Governance
- Gainshare Equity Group, LLC is a Florida limited liability company formed to expand product opportunities in specialty and diverse markets. It receives the reorganized debtor's shares in exchange for new value. The plan describes that new value as contributing to the funding and management of the plan's economics and ownership of the debtor's assets, and does not give it a dollar amount.
- Plan payments and distributions come from postpetition operations, supplemented by Gainshare capital advances for paper and related materials under a contract manufacturing model. The debtor says this model reduces overhead and labor costs.
- Gainshare provides the reorganized debtor's initial management after confirmation. It is responsible for supervising operations, costs, internal controls and supply lines, and for meeting postpetition investment and financing needs. It does this at no cost to the debtor until the debtor emerges from Chapter 11. The articles and bylaws will be amended as needed by the effective date.
- On feasibility, the debtor cites lower operating costs and repairs and maintenance on its prepetition equipment that restored efficiency and throughput. It also cites the surrender of real property and surplus equipment in full satisfaction of specific claims. It describes its projections as conservative and sufficient to support plan payments with minimal growth.
- The plan identifies two risks: customers failing to pay for the debtor's material and labor, and higher materials costs from interest rates, tariffs, logistics costs and commodity market swings, along with labor increases and unforeseen manufacturing and maintenance costs.
Background and Path to Chapter 11
- Envelope 1 was incorporated in Ohio on Nov. 13, 2012. It is the surviving entity of a merger with E1 Digital Direct, an Ohio company formed Aug. 27, 2015, and was domesticated in Florida on Nov. 13, 2025.
- The debtor attributes its distress to ambitious financing decisions and real property investments, including the new facility for digital and other advanced printing. It says management, looking back, did not measure the cost of carrying an eight-figure increase in leveraged financing at rates above 15%. Margins then fell as the debtor expanded output and discounted its products. Keeping skilled manufacturing staff for more than a year further strained cash flow and limited its ability to buy raw materials. Seeking short-term relief, the debtor took on interest-only hard money loans and merchant cash advances, which cut daily cash flow further, while the enlarged facility was barely used. Before filing, it moved its nerve center to Boca Raton, Florida, to attract higher-tech personnel and reach local markets.
- Since filing, the debtor has operated as a smaller manufacturer on a cash basis, with a new internal control system, lower-cost staff and raw materials from cooperating vendors. It says its low-volume output is producing mildly profitable sales. It reports staying current on cash collateral obligations, operating payments, payroll tax deposits and U.S. Trustee fees. It says it could not raise new capital on its own.
Liquidation Analysis
- The debtor's liquidation comparison relies on three positions. First, Spectrum's first lien covers receivables and every asset not subject to a purchase-money lien. Second, U.S. Eagle's $23.8 million claim is secured by the surrendered real property and Truepress presses; the liquidation analysis describes both the 2021 and 2017 presses as surrendered, while Class 4 says press #2017 was removed by M2 Equipment Finance. Third, priority tax and wage claims would be paid in full before unsecured creditors receive anything.
- The debtor says substantially all of its equipment is fully depreciated, specific to its business and has no replacement-parts catalog. The equipment is installed or hardwired at its premises, and most of it would be inoperable without the debtor's on-site machine shop. The debtor says rapidly changing technology has cut equipment values substantially, and removal costs plus the risk of damage in transit limit its value to a third party to little above salvage.
- The debtor tried to market the equipment securing the purchase-money liens and contacted its manufacturer. The manufacturer quoted $89,000 to remove each machine and an additional $89,000 to reinstall the equipment at a new location, with no guarantee it would work after the move.
- The debtor reviewed transfers made within 90 days before filing and other transfers avoidable over the four-year lookback period. It does not believe any transfers are avoidable or need to be pursued to fund the plan.
Executory Contracts and Leases
- The debtor assumes its Aug. 1, 2022 lease with Verdant Commercial Capital for a Morpho c216 CMYK high-speed system and accessories. It also assumes Byline lease No. 749630, which has 10 payments of $1,444.01 left on its initial term.
- All other executory contracts and unexpired leases that are not listed, already assumed or the subject of a pending assumption motion are rejected. The debtor specifically rejects:
- its merchant cash funding agreements for the sale of future receivables, to the extent they are executory
- its health insurance agreement with Medical Mutual, which the debtor agrees terminated Sept. 1, 2025
- its lease with Pidgeon Envelope, LLC
- any lease with the nondebtor entity whose real property is subject to NuBridge's foreclosure judgment, effective on the effective date
Key Dates
- Petition date: Nov. 12, 2025.
- Claims bar dates: Jan. 21, 2026 for nongovernmental claims and May 13, 2026 for governmental claims.
- Spectrum payoff installments: $300,000 due by July 31, 2026 and $300,000 due by Sept. 30, 2026. Gainshare made the first payment but not the second.
- Effective date: the first business day after the date 30 days after the confirmation order becomes final. If the confirmation order is stayed on that date, it is the first business day after the stay ends.
- Rejection damages claims: due 30 days after the effective date.
Discharge and Other Provisions
- On the effective date, the debtor is discharged from debts that arose before confirmation, except obligations imposed by the plan and debts excepted under section 1141(d)(6).
- The plan proponent may modify the plan before confirmation, though the court may require a new disclosure statement or a new vote. After confirmation and before plan payments are complete, the debtor, the U.S. Trustee or any holder of an allowed unsecured claim may seek a modification to:
- increase or reduce payments to a class
- lengthen or shorten the payment period
- adjust a creditor's distribution for payments made outside the plan
- No prepayment penalty applies to any claim. No postpetition interest, penalties, late charges or attorneys' fees are allowed on claims unless the plan provides for them or the court awards them.
- No distribution is made on a disputed claim until a final, non-appealable order allows it. The debtor may settle disputed claims with court approval and reserves the right to object to any claim not already allowed by final order.
- A creditor that missed the bar date cannot recover more than, or a claim of a different nature from, what the debtor scheduled as liquidated, undisputed and noncontingent; an amendment to a timely proof of claim filed after the bar date without the debtor's consent or a court order is deemed disallowed without further order.
- After the effective date, the court keeps exclusive jurisdiction over claims disputes, professional fee applications, pending matters, plan modifications, enforcement of distributions and any orders needed to carry out the plan.