Lisbon Vista Heights - Chapter 11 Plan Terms
Lisbon Vista Heights’ plan of reorganization centers on a sale of its stalled 24-home subdivision in San Diego before construction is complete, whereby an expected $7.1 million in net sale proceeds, along with any refinancing proceeds, litigation recoveries or capital contributions, would pay all allowed claims in full, including construction lender Center Street Lending’s estimated $4.3 million secured claim and the disputed claims of former general contractor HM Constructor. Every class is designated unimpaired, and nonprofit parent Bay Vista Methodist Heights retains its membership interests and any residual proceeds.
Plan Terms
Overview
- Lisbon Vista Heights, LLC's updated plan of reorganization would pay all allowed claims in full from a sale of the debtor's stalled 24-home subdivision project in San Diego, with the sale to close before construction is complete. The debtor filed the plan and an updated disclosure statement on Nov. 12, 2026.
- Every class is designated unimpaired. The debtor's nonprofit parent, Bay Vista Methodist Heights, Inc., holds all of the debtor's membership interests and keeps them. The parent also receives any proceeds left after all claims are paid.
- Claims are paid from any combination of four sources: net sale proceeds, refinancing proceeds, net litigation recoveries and capital contributions, including from the parent. The plan authorizes a refinancing, which the debtor says could lead to earlier payment.
- The effective date is three business days after the debtor receives the net sale proceeds. Each class of claims is paid within five business days after that.
- The debtor believes no class is impaired. It is still soliciting votes from all classes so the plan can be confirmed if the court finds any class impaired, and it will seek cramdown under section 1129(b) against any impaired class that rejects the plan.
Sources and Uses of Sale Proceeds
- The debtor expects net sale proceeds of $7.1 million. That figure assumes gross proceeds of $7.65 million, the same as the property's as-is appraised value, less estimated closing costs of $550,000.
- Projected uses total $6.643 million and consist of:
- administrative claims, $60,000
- U.S. Trustee fees, $50,000
- Class 1, $20,000
- Class 2, an estimated $4.3 million
- Class 3A, an estimated $620,000 (disputed)
- Class 3B, an estimated $1.3 million (disputed)
- Class 3C, an estimated $253,000 (disputed)
- Classes 3D and 4, nothing
- Class 5, $40,000
- The disclosure statement bases its U.S. Trustee fee estimate on post-confirmation disbursements of up to $5.5 million and its Chapter 7 trustee-fee comparison on distributions of $5.5 million, while its table of projected uses of sale proceeds totals $6.643 million.
- The debtor names two main risks:
- the property may sell for less than expected, a risk it says would show up, if at all, before the effective date
- the Class 2 claim of construction lender Center Street Lending VIII SPE, LLC, or CSL, may turn out larger than expected, leaving less for other classes; if it is large enough, other classes, and even Class 2, could be paid less than in full and would become impaired
- To limit those risks, the debtor plans to keep trying to refinance and to sell the property for the highest price within a reasonable time. It estimates the sale at 120 to 150 days after the effective date, although the plan defines the effective date as three business days after the debtor receives the sale proceeds.
Unclassified Claims
- Administrative claims are paid in full in cash on the later of the effective date or allowance by final order. Postpetition ordinary-course liabilities are paid in the ordinary course. Administrative claims must be paid in full before Classes 3B, 3C, 3D, 4, 5 or 6 receive anything.
- General bankruptcy counsel Curry Advisors expects to be owed about $60,000 as of the effective date, which the debtor expects to pay as a professional-fee administrative claim on that date. The parent paid the firm a $12,000 prepetition retainer, of which $6,928.50 remained at the petition date, and a court-authorized $10,000 postpetition retainer.
- The debtor says it is substantially current on postpetition obligations to third parties.
- About $20,000 of postpetition real property taxes will be paid as part of the Class 1 claim.
- If cash runs short on the effective date, the debtor expects administrative claimants to agree to defer payment.
- Requests for payment of administrative claims are due 45 days after the effective date, and late claims are barred and discharged. Four kinds of claims are exempt from that deadline: claims already allowed, ordinary-course liabilities, governmental claims that need not be filed, and U.S. Trustee fees.
- The debtor estimates U.S. Trustee fees of up to about $50,000, based on post-confirmation disbursements of up to $5.5 million, unless it obtains an early final decree.
- The debtor believes there are no priority tax claims. Any that exist are paid, at the debtor's choice, either in cash on or soon after the effective date or in installments ending no later than five years after the petition date. Payment cures any default and disallows related fees, charges and penalties.
- Professional fees after confirmation may be paid without court approval, and disputes go to the court. Any case-related payment outside the Bankruptcy Code's fee-application process is deemed approved as reasonable by the confirmation order unless challenged within 90 days. Only the court, the U.S. Trustee, the payer or the payee may bring that challenge.
Classification and Treatment of Claims and Interests
- Class 1, the San Diego County Treasurer-Tax Collector's secured real property tax claim (unimpaired, deemed to accept): estimated at about $20,000 and secured by a senior general lien on the property. The claim is allowed in the amount the court sets. It is paid from sale proceeds, including all prepetition and postpetition amounts, within five business days after the effective date. Payment cures all defaults and disallows default or penalty interest, late fees and other charges.
- Class 2, CSL's secured claim (unimpaired, deemed to accept): backed by seven promissory notes and deeds of trust, with liens junior only to Class 1.
- The claim is allowed at $4,296,897.78 or another amount the court sets. The debtor believes CSL asserts about $4.7 million.
- It is paid from sale proceeds within five business days after the effective date.
- CSL's loan documents stay in effect, and any cure follows section 1123(d).
- The debtor intends to object to the claim.
- Class 3A, the secured claim of former general contractor HM Constructor, Inc. (unimpaired, deemed to accept): asserted at $619,214.41 under a purported mechanic's lien that is junior to Classes 1 and 2. The claim is disputed and the subject of pending litigation.
- The allowed amount is reduced by the debtor's setoff rights unless a final order finds those rights worthless.
- It is paid in full from sale proceeds within five business days after the effective date, with interest at 3.51% a year from the petition date, or another rate the court sets.
- Payment cures all defaults and disallows default or penalty interest, late fees and other charges.
- Class 3B, HM Constructor's unsecured claim (unimpaired, deemed to accept): asserted at about $1.26 million, disputed and the subject of pending litigation. It is paid in full from sale proceeds within five business days after the effective date, after reduction for the debtor's setoff rights.
- Class 3C, the unsecured claim of HM Constructor's principal, Hector Martinez, other than his guaranty claim (unimpaired, deemed to accept): asserted at $252,145.82, disputed and the subject of pending litigation. It gets the same treatment as Class 3B.
- Class 3D, Martinez's unsecured claim on an alleged personal guaranty (unimpaired, deemed to accept): asserted at about $4.31 million. It is disallowed in full under section 502(e), and any portion later allowed is treated as a Class 3C claim. The plan and the disclosure statement's class description both call this a guaranty of the Class 1 tax claim, while the disclosure statement's summary of the schedules describes a $4.2 million contingent Martinez guaranty that substantially or entirely overlaps CSL's Class 2 claim.
- Class 4, priority wage, salary and commission claims (unimpaired, deemed to accept): the debtor believes there are none. Any such claims are paid in full within five business days after the effective date, and any amount above the statutory priority cap becomes a Class 5 claim.
- Class 5, general unsecured claims (unimpaired, deemed to accept): estimated at about $40,000. The total could be higher if the debtor's new contractor asserts a contract-rejection claim. These claims are paid in full from sale proceeds within five business days after the effective date. Rejection damages fall in this class.
- Class 6, membership interests, all held by the parent (unimpaired, deemed to accept): the parent keeps its interests and receives any liquidation proceeds left after all claims are paid.
- Interest is calculated on a 360-day year regardless of any creditor's agreement. If a creditor challenges its classification, the debtor may seek a ruling through the claims objection process, and that ruling is not a condition to confirmation.
Means of Implementation
- The reorganized debtor may sell some or all of the property. Net sale proceeds are proceeds of a sale made before construction is complete, after sale costs and a reserve for taxes on any gain. They go first to pay or reserve for claims, and any remainder may be used for other purposes consistent with the plan.
- The reorganized debtor may also refinance the property. A refinancing lien used to pay Classes 1, 2 or 3A takes the same priority as the liens it pays off. New capital from any source, including the parent, is authorized.
- The debtor may escrow funds for Classes 2 and 3A instead of paying those holders directly:
- It does so by written notice to counsel for either or both classes, placing enough sale, refinancing, litigation or capital proceeds with a licensed escrow company to pay those claims in the allowed amount the court fixes, possibly at confirmation.
- The liens are then released from the property and attach to the escrowed funds with the same priority.
- Funds are released as claims are allowed. Partial payments are applied as the loan documents provide or, if they are silent, first to principal, then interest, then other charges.
- Once paid, secured creditors must sign lien releases and reconveyances, deposited with an escrow agent where appropriate. If a holder refuses, the lien is deemed released without any recorded release.
- As of the effective date, the debtor's defaults under nonbankruptcy agreements are deemed cured. Any notice of default or sale a creditor recorded before then is void.
- Under sections 506(d) and 551, a lien securing a claim that is not an allowed secured claim is void and preserved for the estate. That includes amounts disallowed through the plan's cure provisions or a negotiated reduction. The estate is paid on the preserved lien pari passu with the lienholder, and avoided transfers are preserved the same way.
- Excess cash may be used in the ordinary course or, at the reorganized debtor's discretion, to prepay creditors.
Key Dates
- Ballots must be received by 5 p.m. Pacific Standard Time on Dec. 29, 2026. The confirmation hearing date and the deadline for objections are to be set in the order approving the disclosure statement.
- The effective date falls three business days after the debtor receives the net sale proceeds. Class distributions are due within five business days after the effective date.
- Administrative claims are due 45 days after the effective date.
- Objections to other claims are due by the first business day after the 120th day after the effective date. The court may extend that deadline at the debtor's request, ex parte and without notice to the affected creditor.
- Under the plan, rejection-damages claims are due 30 days after the confirmation date. The plan defines that date as the first business day after the time to appeal the confirmation order runs out, or after any stay pending appeal ends. The disclosure statement instead gives the deadline as 30 days after the effective date.
- The general bar date was March 13, 2026, and July 1, 2026 for governmental units.
Background and Path to Chapter 11
- The debtor is a California tax-exempt entity formed to develop 7108-7112 Lisbon Street in San Diego. The 3.73-acre site consists of 27 lots, on which the debtor began building before the petition date. It plans 24 single-family homes and up to 24 accessory dwelling units; the disclosure statement describes the homes as affordable, while the appraisal describes 23 market-rate homes and one moderate-income affordable unit. The parent is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit public benefit corporation formed in 1966 by the pastor of St. Paul United Methodist Church of San Diego to provide affordable housing. The debtor has no operations that generate revenue.
- Before the filing, the debtor was in litigation with HM Constructor. The debtor alleges the contractor supplied defective concrete for the project's structural retaining walls, concealed the defect, abandoned the project and knowingly filed overstated mechanic's liens.
- According to the debtor, those actions delayed completion and blocked a refinancing of the construction loan.
- That led to a loan default, and CSL then began a nonjudicial foreclosure.
- The debtor filed Chapter 11 on Jan. 2, 2026, to protect the project's equity, preserve value for creditors and protect its mission of building the homes. It cited an as-is appraisal of $7.65 million against legitimate liens it believes total less than $5.5 million.
- On June 19, 2026, CSL moved for relief from the automatic stay to foreclose or, alternatively, to dismiss the case. The debtor opposed, arguing that a substantial equity cushion adequately protected CSL and that the debtor should at least be allowed to sell or refinance the property in Chapter 11. The court denied the motion by order entered Aug. 27, 2026.
- On the debtor's June 30, 2026 motion, the court extended the debtor's exclusive period through Oct. 29, 2026. The debtor expects to seek a further extension.
- HM Constructor's prepetition lawsuit is stayed as to the debtor. The debtor's cross-complaint against HM Constructor and Martinez is pending.
- The parent has funded the case:
- before the filing, it paid various debtor expenses, including counsel's $12,000 retainer
- after the filing, it lent the debtor $10,000 for counsel's retainer under a July 6, 2026 order that authorized borrowing of up to $20,000
Valuation and Capital Structure
- The most recent appraisal is dated April 18, 2024, and values the property at $7.65 million as is; an update is pending. Bowery Valuation prepared it for CSL, as its client, for loan underwriting.
- The appraisal also gives two other values: a prospective as-complete value of $22.05 million as of Aug. 18, 2025, and total gross home-sale proceeds of $24.075 million. The owner put the remaining construction cost at about $13.3 million.
- The amended schedules show total assets of $18.35 million:
- the property at $7.65 million
- unliquidated litigation claims at $10.7 million
- other personal property of $252
- The schedules show total liabilities of $13.1 million: $4.86 million of secured claims, no priority claims and $8.24 million of general unsecured claims. The unsecured figure includes:
- $2 million of contingent claims
- a $4.2 million contingent guaranty in favor of Martinez that the debtor says substantially or entirely overlaps CSL's Class 2 claim
- a $2 million disputed claim by HM Constructor
Chapter 7 Comparison
- The debtor projects 100% recoveries for all creditors. Because no creditor is in an impaired class, it says the best-interests test does not apply.
- The debtor also argues that creditors would be paid sooner than in Chapter 7, because a trustee would need at least several more months to market and sell the property. It adds that net proceeds would be significantly lower in Chapter 7, since a trustee's statutory fee on distributions of $5.5 million would be about $188,000.
Claim Objections and Retained Causes of Action
- The debtor will object to the claims of HM Constructor and Martinez and keep litigating its own claims against them. It will also object to CSL's Class 2 claim, and it reserves the right to object to any claim.
- The debtor believes it has claims against the company that supplied the defective concrete HM Constructor used at the property. It may also have claims against other third parties, including those entities' insurers. The schedules list unliquidated litigation claims at $10.7 million.
- All causes of action are kept by the reorganized debtor and vest in it, and net recoveries are a plan funding source. Confirmation settles or releases no cause of action unless the plan or confirmation order specifically says so.
- Payments on disputed claims are set aside and held until a final order allows the claim. The reorganized debtor may settle disputed claims and causes of action.
- Distribution checks not cashed within 120 days are void and the funds become property of the reorganized debtor, which may rely on proof-of-claim addresses and need not search for others.
Executory Contracts
- The plan assumes the debtor's construction contract with Desma Construction for the property, unless that contract was assumed earlier or is the subject of a rejection motion filed before the effective date. It rejects all other executory contracts and unexpired leases, including any with HM Constructor or Martinez.
- Rejection damages are treated as prepetition Class 5 claims. A final order denying a rejection motion counts as an assumption.
Events of Default and Remedies
- Events of default under the plan consist of:
- failure to make any plan payment when due, subject to a 30-day grace period
- failure to pay ordinary-course debts and expenses when due, unless an agreement extends or modifies their terms
- failure to comply with any plan provision
- A default must be cured within 30 days after written notice to the reorganized debtor and its counsel. If it is not, any creditor or party in interest with standing, including the U.S. Trustee, may pursue nonbankruptcy remedies without further court order, including levy and judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure.
- The reorganized debtor or any party in interest may ask the court to stay enforcement. Grounds include that no uncured default exists, or that the creditor is adequately protected and the default is likely to be cured within a reasonable time, given the right to seek plan modification. The party seeking the stay bears the burden of proof.
Post-Effective Date Covenants
- Except as the plan otherwise provides, from the effective date the reorganized debtor:
- is barred from filing a future bankruptcy case in another district
- will pay its ordinary debts as they come due
- will not sell, transfer or encumber property outside the ordinary course without a further court order
- will keep its existing insurance unless it becomes unnecessary
- will conduct its financial affairs with good business judgment
Discharge, Injunction and Case-Related Claims
- As of the effective date, plan treatment fully satisfies and discharges all claims against, and interests in, the debtor and its property. This applies whether or not a proof of claim was filed, the claim was allowed or the holder accepted the plan. Creditors are permanently barred from collecting claims discharged or paid under the plan.
- Claims relating to the case against the debtor, its counsel or any estate professional must be brought by adversary proceeding within the later of 45 days after the effective date or 45 days after final fee applications are filed. Otherwise they are barred and released.
- On confirmation, estate property, including causes of action, vests in the reorganized debtor free of claims except as the plan provides. The plan overrides all prior orders, stipulations and agreements in the case unless the plan or confirmation order specifically preserves them.
Plan Modification
- Before confirmation, the debtor may amend or withdraw the plan at any time, though the court may require a new disclosure statement or a new vote.
- After confirmation, the debtor may modify the plan if it meets the Bankruptcy Code's requirements. The disclosure statement describes those as the plan not yet being substantially consummated and the court approving the change after notice and a hearing.
- With court approval, the debtor may fix defects or reconcile inconsistencies that do not materially or adversely affect creditors. Prior votes carry over to a modified plan unless a creditor changes its vote in writing within the time the court sets.